Skip to content. Skip to navigation

Cornell Lab of Ornithology

Sections

Refine Protocols: How-to's

 

Keep objectives in mind and...

  • use proper study design to meet scientific objectives
  • understand and account for potential biases of research design
  • ensure study design also facilitates other objectives (e.g., educational)
  • develop a clearly written protocol

 

Be aware of volunteer abilities/interests,

  • choose protocols within capacity of volunteers (be realistic)
    • is the project overly ambitious (too tedious or complex)?
    • is it underestimating volunteer skills (not interesting/challenging)?
  • keep protocols transparent (observers should know why they're being asked to do things a certain way)
  • plan for reasonable equipment intensity (cost, maintenance, usability)

   

Pilot test data forms that facilitate...

  • users filling in all fields
  • geo-referencing data
  • temporally referencing data
  • collection of negative data
  • identification of observer for each data point
  • early identification of "outliers"
    • allows differentiation of typos from unusual sightings
    • provides an opportunity to request confirmation
 

Plan ahead for usable data,

  • choose protocols within capacity of volunteers
  • ensure the protocols are clearly written and accessible to all participants
  • build ID guides and data confirmation steps into data collection tools
  • consult with a statistician and:
    • determine the necessary sample size for your study
    • determine the necessary number of study sites
    • address the potential for sampling bias
  • decide up front how to handle questionable data
  • pilot test all stages of project development

 

Make smart use of technology,

  • minimize errors by making data collection electronic at the earliest stage
  • but, consider that a pencil and paper datasheet can be sufficient
  • identify particular needs of different users/clients (scientists, volunteers, etc.)
  • provide different data forms for different audiences that collect the same data (e.g., paper and electronic)
  • assess appropriate technology options (see tech tools)
  • be creative and opportunistic

 

"Monetize" data for project efficiency:

  • compare how much it costs to collect...
    • X records of quality A vs...
    • Y records of quality B
  • account for necessary training and support expenses
  • remember to also value and account for other goals (e.g., educational)
  • use efficiency measures to guide protocol design, equipment choices, etc. 

 

Adapt and improve as necessary,

  • respond to pilot tests, formative evaluations, and participant feedback regarding:
    • data forms
    • use of protocols
    • technology tools
    • available training and support
  • make improvements in a timely, transparent, and coherent manner

 


Know of any FTWs for this step?  Soon you will be able to share them through our discussion forum.


 

back arrow Previous Step            Toolkit tiny globe Steps   
  Next Step Go arrow

(form a team)


(recruit participants)