Cornell Lab of Ornithology

bslogo.gif (22710 bytes)
WINTER 2000/VOLUME 14, NUMBER 1

Tanager Guidelines
Become A Member


Conserving Forest Bird Populations
Through Citizen Science

BY Rick Bonney and Ron Rohrbaugh


Please cite this Page as:
Bonney, R. and Rohrbaugh, R. 2000.  Conserving Forest Bird Populations Through Citizen Science. Birdscope, Volume 14, Number 1:  1-3.


Project Tanager yields the first in a series of management guidelines for preserving bird habitat

The Conservation Science program at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology recently published the first in a series of habitat management guidelines designed to help land managers and owners manage and protect habitat for birds. A Land Manager’s Guide to Improving Habitat for Scarlet Tanagers and other Forest-interior Birds rolled off the presses this past December, offering specific habitat management guidelines resulting from one of the Lab’s first citizen-science projects, Project Tanager. The publication of these guidelines shows how effectively citizen-science projects can contribute directly to bird conservation, but more importantly, the guidelines provide land managers with science-based recommendations that they can use immediately.

As the preface of the 24-page booklet explains, these guidelines are written for two types of land managers: those responsible for large landscapes, such as public lands or entire states, and private landowners who manage small blocks of forest. The booklet first discusses the general concept of forest fragmentation-the process by which large, contiguous forests are broken into small parcels by agriculture, logging, or development. Scientists have known for some time that fragmentation can severely reduce the ability of a forest to support healthy breeding populations of many bird species, so the booklet offers general guidelines for managing forests to benefit many forest-interior birds. These general guidelines include preventing the fragmentation of large forest tracts, minimizing the creation of edge habitats, establishing forested corridors to reduce isolation of small patches, and maintaining structural and plant-species diversity within existing forests.

Then, the booklet focuses specifically on the habitat-area requirements of the Scarlet Tanager. Because habitat requirements for this species vary geographically, recommendations are tailored to conditions in different regions of the tanager’s range. Four “Regional Profiles” provide a map and description of available forest types, Project Tanager results showing forest types used by Scarlet Tanagers, estimates of the amount of mature forest required to sustain breeding Scarlet Tanagers, and a regional summary that briefly presents the most important management strategies for that location. This regional approach provides land managers with information that will be directly applicable to their own areas.

Central to each profile are “Minimum Area Tables.” These tables have several uses, for example, predicting the impacts that proposed management actions or land-use changes will have on the suitability of habitat for breeding tanagers or determining the degree of reforestation needed to increase the likelihood of attracting tanagers to a forest patch. The tables must be used carefully and correctly, however, because the suitability of any given forest patch for supporting tanagers depends not only on the size of the patch but also on the amount of forest remaining in the surrounding landscape, as well as the distance from the patch to the nearest forest of at least 100 acres. For example, a 20-acre woodlot may be unlikely to support tanagers if it is surrounded by agricultural land, but a similar woodlot located close to a large, extensively forested park may be almost as likely to support tanagers as the park itself. Indeed, the complexity of the relationship between tanagers and their habitats is one of the key findings of Project Tanager.

This table indicates the minimum area required to provide high-, moderate-, or low-suitability habitat for Scarlet Tanagers in the Midwest region. High-suitability habitats have the same probability of supporting breeding tanagers as unfragmented forests, whereas moderate- and low-suitability habitats are respectively 25 percent and 50 percent less likely to support tanagers than an unfragmented forest.
Percentage of Minimum area(acres)required for:
forest in 2,500-acre block  High Moderate Low
70 66 11 1
60 141 23 3
50 292 47 6
40 605 97 12
30 NA* 208 27
20 NA* 481 62
10 NA* NA* 173

*Not available—acreage values exceed the amount of forest in the 2,500-acre block

Why did the Lab choose the Scarlet Tanager for its first forest-bird project and first set of habitat guidelines? First, this conspicuous species represents a whole community of forest-dwelling Neotropical migratory birds. Scarlet Tanagers are part of a community of species that share similar habitat requirements and geographical distributions. By meeting the needs of Scarlet Tanagers, land managers also will be improving habitat for dozens of other forest-dwelling birds.

Second, although Scarlet Tanager populations are stable in many areas, the species is still vulnerable, because much of its population is concentrated in forests in the northeastern United States and eastern Canada. Also, the best time to begin protecting a species is while it still is common. For these reasons, the tanager served as an excellent pilot species for the Lab’s first continentwide study of forest birds. And now, through Birds in Forested Landscapes, the original tanager protocols have been extended to include forest thrushes and accipiter hawks. Guidelines for these and other species will be prepared in the future.

Improving Habitat for Scarlet Tanagers and other Forest-interior Birds was written by several Lab staff: Ken Rosenberg, Ron Rohrbaugh, Sara Barker, Jim Lowe, Stefan Hames, and André Dhondt. Single copies are available free of charge to all participants in Project Tanager: call the number in the box below to receive one in the mail. For nonparticipants, copies are available for $5.00, which covers the cost of printing and mailing. In an effort to further the Lab’s mission of bird conservation, state and federal agencies and other groups that are responsible for managing large amounts of forest will be provided with complimentary copies of the booklet. The booklet will also be available in electronic form at the Lab’s web site.

We thank the National Science Foundation, National Fish and Wildlife Foundation, Partners in Flight, Archie and Grace Berry Charitable Foundation, Florence and John Schumann Foundation, Packard Foundation, and each participant in Project Tanager for the funding, data, and general support they provided to Project Tanager and for production of this new publication.

Ground-testing Citizen Science with Project Tanager

Studying range-wide effects of landscape features and habitat fragmentation on widespread species such as Scarlet Tanagers is not simple. In fact, no single researcher or team of researchers could adequately cover enough territory during a short breeding season to conduct such a study. For this reason, in 1993 the Lab of Ornithology developed Project Tanager, a partnership between amateur birders and professional scientists, with support from the National Science Foundation and the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation. By employing this volunteer, citizen-scientist work force, Cornell researchers could be “everywhere at once.” From 1993 to 1996, more than 1,000 trained volunteers studied tanagers at more than 2,000 study sites across North America, amassing perhaps the largest data set ever collected on forest fragmentation and its effect on birds.

Project Tanager participants followed a simple but rigorously tested protocol that included selecting suitable study sites; visiting these sites at least twice during the breeding season to search for tanagers and look for evidence of breeding; measuring a suite of habitat variables; and returning data to Cornell for analysis. The newly published Scarlet Tanager management guidelines are a direct result of this massive study.

Rick Bonney and Ron Rorbaugh

Return