Project FeederWatch home page
Canadian FeederWatch page
Project FeederWatch
Overview Instructions and Updates Data Entry Data Retrieval News About Birds and Bird Feeding

Common Redpoll
State Record for New Mexico

Return to Index Page

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

"Improbable as it was, a tundra bird whose normal winter range is far north had found its way to our thistle sock in El Prado, New Mexico!" --Ann Ellen Tuomey

Ann Ellen and James Tuomey found a Common Redpoll on their thistle sock in El Prado, New Mexico, on November 26, 2007. After reporting the bird to the New Mexico Bird Records Committee, they learned that it was the first confirmed sighting of a Common Redpoll in the state of New Mexico. Ann Ellen and James submitted a Rare Bird Form to Project FeederWatch along with photos of the bird. When we asked them if they would like to share the story of how they discovered this rare bird, Ann Ellen sent us a wonderful account of their exciting week. Here are excerpts of her story.

After spending Thanksgiving weekend constantly peering through binoculars for our Project FeederWatch count, on Monday I was taking a break from watching birds. But not my husband, Jim. Since he had spotted both a Western Meadowlark and a Spotted Towhee on Sunday (both infrequent winter visitors) and had just observed this season's first appearance of a Sharp-shinned Hawk, he was too enthused to stop.

"Come here, quick, with your binoculars." I know that command well. After he directed me to the thistle sock, I exclaimed, "Wow, I think it's a Redpoll." And Jim agreed. Neither of us had ever seen a redpoll--only admired its illustration in Sibley when we were checking out other finches.

In my excitement over the sighting I misread the range map of the Common Redpoll, thinking the small bit of winter range in northeast Colorado was in New Mexico. I concluded that the redpoll was uncommon, but not rare. Still I knew it was worth reporting to the New Mexico Audubon Society. That's when things got more interesting.

Photo by Jim Tuomey


We emailed the news of our sighting to our State Audubon Rare Bird Alert and immediately received a response advising us to send a report to the New Mexico Bird Records Committee (NMBRC). We provided the pertinent details to the Committee Secretary: small finch, bright red cap, black lores and throat, pointed yellow bill, forked dark tail, white breast (no pink in breast), streaked flanks, prominent white wing bar; tail of redpoll noticeably longer than that of siskins.

The redpoll didn't show up on Tuesday and neither did a response from the Committee Secretary due to email problems. But Jim noticed a car parked out on our road for several hours. A birder? It turned out that Jerry Oldenette had seen our emails, which were posted on an email list, and had driven about 200 miles to check out our report.

Tuesday night the email came through from the Records Committee
Secretary. "To date, there is no verified record for the species in the
state...most turn out to be Cassin's Finch. However, your written
description sounds very much like Common Redpoll." And the word was out.


Wednesday morning, just after first light, a call came from Jerry Oldenettel, who had stayed overnight nearby for the chance of adding the Common Redpoll to his state list.  He didn't have to wait long. He and another out-of-town birder were shivering in our carport while Jim and I were inside, all with binoculars fixed on a thistle sock hanging from the aspens in front of our house. SHE APPEARED. I quickly dialed Jerry's cell phone and heard his no-nonsense response, "We're looking at it now."

Photo by Jerry Oldenettel

Moments later we, and the birders of New Mexico, had our verification. Jerry, who had just been rewarded for his long trip and great patience, was a member of the NMBRC, and he took several digital photos of our unusual visitor, documenting the sighting.

Once our sighting was confirmed, we were eager to share the news; we notified all the bird enthusiasts we knew and sent a report with photos to Project FeederWatch. In the next seven days, about 40 people-- ranging from high school students to retirees--visited our house in northern New Mexico, and with very few exceptions, observed the female Common Redpoll who fed at our thistle sock frequently for a full week.

We were pleased to have her show up for our FeederWatch count the next weekend. She was last observed on Tuesday, December 4, a week and a day after Jim first spotted her. We miss the sightings as well as the enthusiastic, interesting, and knowledgeable people who came to see the bird, many bearing gifts of thistle seed. But now we can enjoy the raptors that visit our feeder area without worrying that one of them will catch the redpoll.

Our excitement reached its peak when we received this message from Sartor O. Williams of the New Mexico Bird Records Committee, "We've been waiting for this species to show up in the state for many years. It's great to finally get it confirmed." Yes, it's great.

Learn more about the Common Redpoll and see a map showing the normal range of this irruptive finch.

 
© 2007 Express written permission required for use of images or text on these pages.
FeederWatch is a joint research and education project of:
Cornell Lab of Ornithology Home Page
Bird Studies Canada